Welcome to Mark Skousen's Website: Independent Thought for Independent Thinkers


December 8, 2000

Dear Family, Friends, and Subscribers,

Like many other families across the nation, on Thanksgiving afternoon we turned off the television (after one final quick look at the scores--the Florida vote, not the football games) and headed to the movie theater to watch Ron Howard's new version of How the Grinch Stole Christmas. There were many elements to enjoy about this new live-action version: the colorful set and creative costumes so true to Dr. Seuss's style, Jim Carrey's earnest enthusiasm for entertaining, and lovely little Cindy Lou Who. I was moved by the dedication to Howard's mother, "Who loved Christmas the most." She frequently appeared in his movies and passed away this year. I'll miss her too.

But I think Ron Howard, for all his enthusiasm and love for Christmas, may have missed the point--or maybe he was making a point more in keeping with today's audiences. While focusing on his imagined "prequel" of how the Grinch became so Grinchian, he changed what it was about Whoville that made it so Wholy. Gone are the trust and innocence that characterized Seuss's Whos. The inhabitants of Howard's Whoville just don't have it. We meet numerous stock characters that inhabit successful holiday movies: the self-serving politician, the mean-spirited school children, the bickering neighbors, the overzealous shoppers. Even Cindy Lou Who is a cynic. But we don't see any of the true Christmas spirit in this Whoville. There isn't an innocent in the bunch.

I believe Dr. Seuss used his simple children's story to explore a not-so-simple question: What would you have if you had nothing left materially? And will it be enough when you leave this earthly world behind? It's an important question that deserves more than a stock answer.

Recently I reread my favorite Christmas story, Taylor Caldwell's My Christmas Miracle. Writing in first person, she tells the story of a divorced mother in the 1920s, jobless, penniless, about to be evicted, on Christmas Eve. She writes,

"The stormy air was full of the sounds of Christmas merriment as I walked from the streetcar to my small apartment. Bells rang and children shouted in the bitter dusk of the evening, and windows were lighted and everyone was running and laughing. But there would be no Christmas for me, I knew, no gifts, no remembrance whatsoever. As I struggled through the snowdrifts, I just about reached the lowest point in my life. Unless a miracle happened I would be homeless in January, foodless, jobless. I had prayed steadily for weeks, and there had been no answer but this coldness and darkness, this harsh air, this abandonment. God and men had completely forgotten me. I felt old as death, and as lonely. What was to become of us?"

Caldwell's agony had nothing to do with gifts or presents. It was a lack of presence--the presence of One watching over and sustaining her, the remembrance, not the gifts. She describes the bleakness of eating their supper of canned food and facing the sheaf of bills while her child slept. But there is one bright hope, her little daughter, Peggy. "I put Peggy to bed," she writes, "... and a sweet peace flooded me like a benediction. I had some hope again....I opened the two white envelopes. One contained a check for $30 from a company I had worked for briefly in the summer. It was, said a note, my 'Christmas bonus.' My rent! The other envelope was an offer of a permanent position with the government, to begin two days after Christmas. I sat with the letter in my hand and the check on the table before me, and I think that was the most joyful moment of my life up to that time."

When Dr. Seuss's Whovillians wake up to an empty Christmas morning, they meet at the village square to commune with one another and sing carols. The actual words are nonsensical, but to me they sound very much like Adoramos, "we adore thee." In the classic 1966 animated version, a bright star rises up from the town to fill the sky, symbolizing the fact that the true spirit of Christmas--Jesus Christ--resides in that community. When the Grinch realizes that "Maybe Christmas doesn't come from a store; maybe Christmas, perhaps, is a little bit more!" his heart bursts within him. He gets it. Christmas isn't about our gifts to others; it's about God's gift to us.

My youngest daughter's favorite part is when the circle of villagers opens to let the Grinch in. I used to think that it was just cheap animation--the producers didn't want to pay the animators what it would take to draw the villagers actually stepping back, so they just moved the five of them as one piece. But when I watched it on Thanksgiving evening (after the movie we had to come home and watch the original) I realized that maybe Dr. Seuss didn't cut corners. Maybe, perhaps, he was making a statement. The villagers had created a circle that enveloped each other, but that circle unwittingly formed a wall that seemed to keep strangers out. As the Grinch comes to join them, their circle becomes a gate, swinging open to let him in.

Perhaps it wasn't just the Grinch whose heart needed to grow a bit. Even Whos can become Wholier.

This desire for presence--the presence of others--is ubiquitous. After her Christmas miracle, Caldwell describes the overwhelming urge to join with others as she ends her story:

"The church bells began to ring. ... Everywhere people were walking to church to celebrate the birth of the Saviour. People smiled at me and I smiled back. The storm had stopped, the sky was pure and glittering with stars.

"'The Lord is born!' sang the bells to the crystal night and the laughing darkness. Someone began to sing, 'Come all ye faithful!' I joined in and sang with the strangers all about me.

"I am not alone at all, I thought. I was never alone at all.

"And that, of course, is the message of Christmas. We are never alone. Not when the night is darkest, the wind coldest, the world seemingly most indifferent. For this is still the time God chooses."

As one who loves to orchestrate the joyous surprises for Christmas morning, even at the expense of some worried pre-Christmas apprehension on the part of my little ones, I love the thought of God getting involved too. I imagine Him withholding her check and job offer until Christmas Eve, a loving Parent anticipating the joy of the perfect Christmas surprise, knowing how much more it will mean to her now.

May God choose the best for you this season, and may you have the wisdom to recognize His Presence.

-- Jo Ann Skousen

email: jaskousen@mskousen.com


Return to the Index of Jo Ann's Odds & Trends articles:
Return to Index of Articles